Affliate Disclaimer: When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Swipe Previous
Swipe Next
Department 56 - Seasons Bay - I'm Wishing Collectibles for Sale
Year Released: 1998 -- Year Retired: 2001
Collection: Seasons Bay Series Accessories
Part Number: 56.53309
| eBay Summary - Currency Code: USD | Count | Avg. Price (USD) | Low Price (USD) | High Price (USD) |
| Bid Auctions | 1 | 6.00 | 6.00 | 6.00 |
| Buy it Now Auctions | 98 | 13.92 | 4.99 | 85.99 |
Listed below are current active eBay auctions for this collectible.
Click on the image or link to see more details about the auction on eBay.
98 Open
Current eBay Auctions
Title: Dept 56 Seasons Bay - I'm Wishing - BRAND NEW - 53309
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $4.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Erie, US
Seller Rating: 1380/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $4.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Erie, US
Seller Rating: 1380/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 Christmas village wishing well 2.5 inches high
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Livermore, US
Seller Rating: 2876/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Livermore, US
Seller Rating: 2876/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 Season’s Bay Series "I’m Wishing" #53309 EUC Wishing Well
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.00
Item location: Smithton, US
Seller Rating: 340/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.00
Item location: Smithton, US
Seller Rating: 340/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept. 56 I’m Wishing Well Metal Figure 2” Season’s Bay #53309 Miniature
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.25
Item location: Eagle Lake, US
Seller Rating: 12665/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.25
Item location: Eagle Lake, US
Seller Rating: 12665/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Seasons Bay “I’m Wishing” #53309 NEW! Childhood
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.48 or Best Offer
Item location: Charlottesville, US
Seller Rating: 1378/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.48 or Best Offer
Item location: Charlottesville, US
Seller Rating: 1378/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 ~ Season’s Bay Series ~ I’m Wishing Accessory ~ #53309 ~ NIB
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.59 or Best Offer
Item location: Pedricktown, US
Seller Rating: 14622/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.59 or Best Offer
Item location: Pedricktown, US
Seller Rating: 14622/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Vintage 2.5 " Dept 56 Christmas Village Figure Wishing Well
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.99
Item location: Clarksville, US
Seller Rating: 415/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.99
Item location: Clarksville, US
Seller Rating: 415/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 Seasons Bay I'm Wishing Figurine #53309
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Evergreen Park, US
Seller Rating: 1325/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Evergreen Park, US
Seller Rating: 1325/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Seasons Bay I'm Wishing 2 children Wishing Well Bucket #53309 Figurine
Currency: USD
Current Bid Price: $6.00 ( 0 bids)
Buy It Now Price: 8.00
Auction Ends: 13th October, 2026
Item location: Belvidere, US
Seller Rating: 2509/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Current Bid Price: $6.00 ( 0 bids)
Buy It Now Price: 8.00
Auction Ends: 13th October, 2026
Item location: Belvidere, US
Seller Rating: 2509/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 Seasons Bay "I'm Wishing" 1998, Boy & Girl by Wishing Well #53309
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $6.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Baden, US
Seller Rating: 1299/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $6.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Baden, US
Seller Rating: 1299/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 Seasons Bay I'M WISHING WELL # 53309 w/ CHILDREN NEW $6.95
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $6.95
Item location: Westminster, US
Seller Rating: 1207/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $6.95
Item location: Westminster, US
Seller Rating: 1207/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: NEW & FACTORY SEALED Department 56 Seasons Bay I'm Wishing (Wishing Well) #53309
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $6.99
Item location: Windsor, US
Seller Rating: 8259/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $6.99
Item location: Windsor, US
Seller Rating: 8259/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 I'M WISHING Seasons Bay Village Accessory Department 56 NEW IN BOX
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $7.00 or Best Offer
Item location: East Brunswick, US
Seller Rating: 1311/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $7.00 or Best Offer
Item location: East Brunswick, US
Seller Rating: 1311/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: DEPARTMENT 56 SEASONS BAY I'm Wishing 1pc 2 Fig w/Well 53309 MIB
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $7.50
Item location: Island Heights, US
Seller Rating: 8113/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $7.50
Item location: Island Heights, US
Seller Rating: 8113/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept. 56 Seasons I’m Wishing Ceramic Figure Mint in Box
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $7.95 or Best Offer
Item location: Pittstown, US
Seller Rating: 8984/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $7.95 or Best Offer
Item location: Pittstown, US
Seller Rating: 8984/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 Season's Bay I'm Wishing 53309 In Original Box
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $7.99
Item location: Appleton, US
Seller Rating: 6641/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $7.99
Item location: Appleton, US
Seller Rating: 6641/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 Seasons Bay I'm Wishing Figurine #53309
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $7.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Midlothian, US
Seller Rating: 1194/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $7.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Midlothian, US
Seller Rating: 1194/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept. 56 Seasons Bay “ I'm Wishing" Village Figurine #53309
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $7.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Washington, US
Seller Rating: 1825/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $7.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Washington, US
Seller Rating: 1825/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Seasons Bay Accessory I'M WISHING Wishing Well #53309
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $8.00
Item location: Medina, US
Seller Rating: 43215/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $8.00
Item location: Medina, US
Seller Rating: 43215/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: 1998 RETIRED DEPARTMENT 56 SEASONS BAY SERIES I'M WISHING ACCESSORY
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $8.00
Item location: Billings, US
Seller Rating: 2410/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $8.00
Item location: Billings, US
Seller Rating: 2410/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 Seasons Bay Water well I'M WISHING #53309
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $8.50 or Best Offer
Item location: Garden Grove, US
Seller Rating: 838/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $8.50 or Best Offer
Item location: Garden Grove, US
Seller Rating: 838/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Vintage 2.5 " Dept 56 Christmas Village Figure Wishing Well
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $8.90 or Best Offer
Item location: Chesnee, US
Seller Rating: 655/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $8.90 or Best Offer
Item location: Chesnee, US
Seller Rating: 655/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 Seasons Bay I'm Wishing # 53309 (Wishing Well) (sealed!) (C4)
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $8.95
Item location: San Antonio, US
Seller Rating: 6321/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $8.95
Item location: San Antonio, US
Seller Rating: 6321/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Seasons Bay I'm Wishing 53309 Village Figurine Accessory NIB NEW SEALED
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $8.98 or Best Offer
Item location: Bay Minette, US
Seller Rating: 1721/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $8.98 or Best Offer
Item location: Bay Minette, US
Seller Rating: 1721/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: 1998 DEPARTMENT 56 SEASONS BAY CERAMIC #53309--I'M WISHING--NEW IN BOX
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $8.99
Item location: Olar, US
Seller Rating: 2469/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $8.99
Item location: Olar, US
Seller Rating: 2469/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56-Season's Bay- I'm Wishing-#53309
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.00
Item location: Colmar, US
Seller Rating: 8200/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.00
Item location: Colmar, US
Seller Rating: 8200/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: DEPARTMENT 56 SEASONS BAY “I'M WISHING” #53309 NIB Figurine Accessory
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.59 or Best Offer
Item location: Gettysburg, US
Seller Rating: 4429/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.59 or Best Offer
Item location: Gettysburg, US
Seller Rating: 4429/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: 1998 DEPARTMENT 56 SEASONS BAY CERAMIC #53309--I'M WISHING--NEW IN BOX
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.74 or Best Offer
Item location: Commack, US
Seller Rating: 5159/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.74 or Best Offer
Item location: Commack, US
Seller Rating: 5159/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: 1998 DEPARTMENT 56 SEASONS BAY CERAMIC #53309--I'M WISHING--NEW IN BOX
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.74 or Best Offer
Item location: Commack, US
Seller Rating: 5159/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.74 or Best Offer
Item location: Commack, US
Seller Rating: 5159/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 ~ Seasons Bay ~ I’m Wishing ~ #56.53309 ~ EUC
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99
Item location: Elk Grove Village, US
Seller Rating: 1055/99.3%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99
Item location: Elk Grove Village, US
Seller Rating: 1055/99.3%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Seasons Bay ~ I'm Wishing ~ 53309
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99
Item location: Waynesboro, US
Seller Rating: 10022/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99
Item location: Waynesboro, US
Seller Rating: 10022/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Precious Moments Christmas Ornament Wishing You A Cozy Christmas 1986 Figurine
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Saint Paul, US
Seller Rating: 187/98.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Saint Paul, US
Seller Rating: 187/98.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 I'm Wishing Season's Bay #53309 Village Accessories Wishing Well
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Mcminnville, US
Seller Rating: 2581/99.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Mcminnville, US
Seller Rating: 2581/99.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 ~ Season’s Bay Series ~ I’m Wishing Accessory ~ #53309 ~ NIB
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Springfield, US
Seller Rating: 3294/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Springfield, US
Seller Rating: 3294/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 Seasons Bay I'm Wishing Vintage 1998 Hand Painted #53309
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Mcminnville, US
Seller Rating: 2581/99.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Mcminnville, US
Seller Rating: 2581/99.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Seasons Bay I'm Wishing 53309 Retired Boxed
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Boynton Beach, US
Seller Rating: 4247/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Boynton Beach, US
Seller Rating: 4247/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Snow village lemax style Christmas village Cobblestone Wishing Well
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99 or Best Offer
Item location: New Port Richey, US
Seller Rating: 4937/99.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99 or Best Offer
Item location: New Port Richey, US
Seller Rating: 4937/99.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept. 56 Seasons Bay I'm Wishing #53309 Hand Painted Metal Piece NIB
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99
Item location: Goodells, US
Seller Rating: 12869/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $9.99
Item location: Goodells, US
Seller Rating: 12869/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: VILLAGE DEPT 56 SEASON'S BAY - MINIATURE I'M WISHING #53309 WISHING WELL
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $10.00
Item location: Red Bank, US
Seller Rating: 2134/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $10.00
Item location: Red Bank, US
Seller Rating: 2134/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: DEPARTMENT 56 SEASONS BAY "I'M WISHING" 1998 BOY & GIRL BY WISHING WELL #53309
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $10.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Argos, US
Seller Rating: 680/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $10.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Argos, US
Seller Rating: 680/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Precious Moments Wishing You A Purrfect Holiday Ornament 1990
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $10.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Saybrook, US
Seller Rating: 6105/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $10.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Saybrook, US
Seller Rating: 6105/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: DEPT 56 VILLAGE - SEASONS BAY - I'M WISHING 53309 RETIRED ACCESSORY MINT
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $10.50 or Best Offer
Item location: San Gabriel, US
Seller Rating: 1828/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $10.50 or Best Offer
Item location: San Gabriel, US
Seller Rating: 1828/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: DEPT 56 SEASONS BAY I'M WISHING FIGURINE
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $10.66 or Best Offer
Item location: Nixa, US
Seller Rating: 3732/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $10.66 or Best Offer
Item location: Nixa, US
Seller Rating: 3732/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept. 56 Seasons Bay “ I'm Wishing" Village Figurine #53309
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $10.79
Item location: Modesto, US
Seller Rating: 25400/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $10.79
Item location: Modesto, US
Seller Rating: 25400/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Seasons Bay - I'm Wishing #53309 Wishing Well
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $10.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Eddington, US
Seller Rating: 1461/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $10.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Eddington, US
Seller Rating: 1461/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Seasons Bay ~ I'm Wishing ~ Mint In Box 53309
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $10.99
Item location: Cypress, US
Seller Rating: 14828/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $10.99
Item location: Cypress, US
Seller Rating: 14828/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 I'm Wishing Seasons Bay Christmas Village House 53309 3
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $11.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Beaverton, US
Seller Rating: 2862/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $11.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Beaverton, US
Seller Rating: 2862/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Seasons Bay "I’m Wishing” Figurine #53309 Excellent, Rare & Boxed
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $11.89 or Best Offer
Item location: Tomah, US
Seller Rating: 2067/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $11.89 or Best Offer
Item location: Tomah, US
Seller Rating: 2067/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
98 Open
Back to the top
Last Updated October 12, 2026, 5:26 am America/New_York
Copyright © 2026 N. & C. Stevens
Privacy Policy
➤